| | | | | | . | QUARTERBACK | | | | | . | | TEAM | # | NAME | | . | 1st Team | Lackawanna Dynasty | 4 | Ray Braxton | | . | 2nd Team | WPA Warhawks | 7 | Matt Kershey | | . | 3rd Team | Cleveland Saints | 8 | Albert Wilhelmy | | . | Hon. Mention | Ceredo Kenova Crash | 8 | Justin Lunsford | | . | | | | | | . | HALFBACK | | | | | . | | TEAM | # | NAME | | . | 1st Team | Lackawanna Dynasty | 23 | James Henley | | . | 2nd Team | Lockport Rage | 20 | P.J. Harris | | . | 3rd Team | Nickel City Kings | 5 | Marcus Davis | | . | Hon. Mention | WV Lightning | 4 | Jerome Smith | | . | | | | | | . | FULLBACK | | | | | . | | TEAM | # | NAME | | . | 1st Team | Pittsburgh Pride | 45 | Geno Hopkins | | . | 2nd Team | Cleveland Saints | 29 | Chip McClain | | . | 3rd Team | Nickel City Kings | 6 | Mike Amos | | . | Hon. Mention | Lackawanna Dynasty | 10 | Claude Scott | |
|
| | | | | | . | | | | | | . | TIGHT END | | | | | . | | TEAM | # | NAME | | . | 1st Team | Lackawanna Dynasty | 84 | Jose Navarez | | . | 2nd Team | Akron Jagz | 11 | Brian Carothers | | . | 3rd Team | NY State Lions | 0 | Shanon Richardson | | . | | | | | | . | WIDE RECEIVER | | | | | . | | TEAM | # | NAME | | . | 1st Team | WV Lightning | 2 | Kenny Davis | | . | 1st Team | Lackawanna Dynasty | 11 | Ricky Winston | | . | 2nd Team | Cleveland Saints | 11 | David Soucie | | . | 2nd Team | NY State Lions | 18 | Rayshawn Bolden | | . | 3rd Team | Lockport Rage | 4 | Jeremy Brown | | . | 3rd Team | Lackawanna Dynasty | 19 | Derrick Dilbert | | . | Hon. Mention | Lackawanna Dynasty | 28 | Rodney Randolph | | . | Hon. Mention | Ceredo Kenova Crash | 6 | Sam Huff | | . | | | | | | . | OFFENSIVE LINEMAN | | | | | . | | TEAM | # | NAME | |
|
| | | | | | . | 1st Team | Lackawanna Dynasty | 77 | Kentay Koram | | . | 1st Team | Lackawanna Dynasty | 56 | Don McDue | | . | 1st Team | Ceredo Kenova Crash | 75 | Jesse Carmon | | . | 1st Team | WV Lightning | 73 | Mike Bonartaro | | . | 1st Team | WV Lightning | 60 | Chris Hughes | | . | 2nd Team | Cleveland Saints | 75 | Rodger Gibson | | . | 2nd Team | Pittsburgh Pride | 50 | Nick Seinera | | . | 2nd Team | WV Gladiators | 63 | Rich Maxwell | | . | 2nd Team | Akron Jagz | 75 | Donny Witt | | . | 2nd Team | Nickel City Kings | 94 | Valdaz Williams | | . | 3rd Team | Cleveland Saints | 73 | Marshall Dillon | | . | 3rd Team | WV Gladiators | 69 | Tim Koon | | . | 3rd Team | Mountain State Bruins | 70 | Travis Keiper | | . | 3rd Team | NY State Lions | 56 | Jermaine Whitt | | . | 3rd Team | Cleveland Saints | 69 | Matt Sobey | | . | Hon. Mention | Nickel City Kings | 52 | Demario Roland | | . | Hon. Mention | NY State Lions | 90 | Michael Whitt | | . | Hon. Mention | Lockport Rage | 66 | J.J. Brice | | . | Hon. Mention | WPA Warhawks | 53 | Mike Miller | | . | Hon. Mention | WPA Warhawks | 55 | Alex Humphries | |
|
| | | | | | . | | | | | | . | DEFENSIVE TACKLE | | | | | . | | TEAM | # | NAME | | . | 1st Team | North Coast Vikings | 4 | Aaron Holderman | | . | 1st Team | Lackawanna Dynasty | 90 | Terrance Ware | | . | 2nd Team | Lackawanna Dynasty | 93 | Brandon Lowe | | . | 2nd Team | NY State Lions | 2 | Brandon Randell | | . | 3rd Team | Ceredo Kenova Crash | 45 | Web Pannelle | | . | 3rd Team | WPA Warhawks | 77 | Rob Moore | | . | Hon. Mention | Lockport Rage | 50 | Dallas Bell | | . | Hon. Mention | Pittsburgh Pride | 95 | Keith Smith | | . | | | | | | . | DEFENSIVE END | | | | | . | | TEAM | # | NAME | | . | 1st Team | Nickel City Kings | 3 | Joseph Littlejohn | | . | 1st Team | Lockport Rage | 55 | Marcus Wyche | | . | 2nd Team | Pittsburgh Pride | 6 | Paul Scott | | . | 2nd Team | Pittsburgh Pride | 20 | Cameron Broadus | | . | 3rd Team | North Coast Vikings | 82 | Joe Tucholski | | . | 3rd Team | NY State Lions | 0 | Shanon Richardson | |
|
| | | | | | . | Hon. Mention | NY State Lions | 12 | Marquell Williams | | . | Hon. Mention | WPA Warhawks | 44 | Randy Snow | | . | | | | | | . | LINEBACKER | | | | | . | | TEAM | # | NAME | | . | 1st Team | Lockport Rage | 7 | Greg Rogers | | . | 1st Team | Lackawanna Dynasty | 1 | Le'Sean Braxton | | . | 1st Team | Lackawanna Dynasty | 8 | Jason Truman | | . | 2nd Team | WV Lightning | 23 | Thomas Abernathy | | . | 2nd Team | North Coast Vikings | 18 | Brian Landies | | . | 2nd Team | North Coast Vikings | 30 | Tom Zapp | | . | 3rd Team | Nickel City Kings | 10 | Micah Harris | | . | 3rd Team | Pittsburgh Pride | 38 | Darron Jett | | . | 3rd Team | NY State Lions | 00 | Gerald Houge | | . | Hon. Mention | Nickel City Kings | 28 | Andrew Williams | | . | Hon. Mention | WV Lightning | 00 | Willie Hampton | | . | Hon. Mention | Mountain State Bruins | 10 | Mitch Kasee | | . | | | | | | . | CORNERBACK | | | | | . | | TEAM | # | NAME | |
|
| | | | | | . | 1st Team | Lackawanna Dynasty | 7 | Peter Ngyuen | | . | 1st Team | Pittsburgh Pride | 26 | Darrell Wolford | | . | 2nd Team | North Coast Vikings | 9 | Terrell Cheatham | | . | 2nd Team | Lackawanna Dynasty | 5 | Nelvin Wilder | | . | 3rd Team | Akron Jagz | 4 | Rico Stamps | | . | 3rd Team | WV Gladiators | 22 | Ben Bradley | | . | Hon. Mention | Lockport Rage | 6 | Jhamal Fluellen | | . | Hon. Mention | WPA Warhawks | 0 | Rashawn Tarver | | . | | | | | | . | SAFETY | | | | | . | | TEAM | # | NAME | | . | 1st Team | NY State Lions | 13 | Terrell Henry | | . | 1st Team | WV Gladiators | 21 | Marcus Law | | . | 2nd Team | Cleveland Saints | 2 | Jerry Adams | | . | 2nd Team | WPA Warhawks | 4 | Alex Simmons | | . | 3rd Team | WV Lightning | 10 | Chad Hudnall | | . | 3rd Team | North Coast Vikings | 5 | Charles Sanders | | . | Hon. Mention | Lockport Rage | 30 | Cliff Mcdowell | | . | Hon. Mention | Akron Jagz | 26 | Marcus Muster | | . | | | | | |
|
| | | | | | . | K/P RETURNER | | | | | . | | TEAM | # | NAME | | . | 1st Team | Pittsburgh Pride | 26 | Darrell Wolford | | . | 2nd Team | WV Lightning | 7 | T.R. Dues | | . | 3rd Team | Nickel City Kings | 14 | Jeremy Wiggins | | . | Hon. Mention | Mountain State Bruins | 12 | Deon Staunton | | . | | | | | | . | KICKER | | | | | . | | TEAM | # | NAME | | . | 1st Team | North Coast Vikings | 15 | Daniel Bartulovic | | . | 2nd Team | Cleveland Saints | 13 | Micheal Rutkowski | | . | 3rd Team | Akron Jagz | 87 | Ryan Smith | | . | Hon. Mention | Mountain State Bruins | 0 | Aaron Childers | | . | | | | | | . | PUNTER | | | | | . | | TEAM | # | NAME | | . | 1st Team | WV Lightning | 27 | Tony Dunbar | | . | 2nd Team | WPA Warhawks | 17 | Jarod Thomas | | . | 3rd Team | Akron Jagz | 87 | Ryan Smith | | . | | | | | |
|
| | | | | | . | SPECIAL TEAMS | | | | | . | | TEAM | # | NAME | | . | 1st Team | Cleveland Saints | 1 | Lawrence Vickerstaff | | . | 2nd Team | Pittsburgh Pride | 16 | Terryll Little | | . | 3rd Team | WV Gladiators | 17 | Chris Crane | | . | Hon. Mention | WV Gladiators | 11 | Paul Lawn | |
|